BS”D
Bamidbar -
How do I love you, let me count the ways.
Dr M Banks – Devar Yerushalayim
We are starting the book of Bamidbar,
the parsha Bamidbar. We are
coming round the corner on the final stretch. Why? Because it
is the 46th day of the Omer. We’re going into Shabbos
tonight. We’re now in Rosh Chodesh, just a few days
until we’ll be getting ready for the ultimate arrival – the arrival of Matan Torah. More than we have been counting the Omer, H’
has been counting us. Counting us for the Torah we will be receiving this year.
Our prayers are for all
Rabbi Beryl Wine, on this weeks parsha, asks a question. The count of the people and the recording of the names of the leaders of the tribes which forms a major part of this sidra, is especially bitter-sweet to the reader of this weeks parsha who knows in advance that all those counted and named with the exception of just three, are doomed to die in the desert, never to reach the land of Israel. The Torah also knows that. So why did the Torah bother to count them in so much detail, with all the names, when it appears to have no relation to the division of the land amongst the Jewish people who would conquer and settle the land of Israel. His answer is as thought provoking today as it may have been back then. There is here a great, important and relevant message for all generations of Jews throughout History. That is not realizing the tragedy of opportunity lost. Greatness squandered and inheritance that is brought to naught. We have to contemplate what H’ had in mind for us, and the tragedy of letting these brochos, like diamonds slide through our fingers and disappear in the desert sand.
So, as I mentioned before, it seems, that were coming round
the final corner to the final stretch, not just in this weeks parsha, sefer Bamdibar,
Rosh Chodesh and Erev
Shabbos, on the brink of Shavuos which is the most
mystical and miraculous of all the Chagim. The Vilna Gaon said that you could put an external human limb to some
Chagim, Pesach the legs, with the Matza,
Seder, Sraifas HaChometz,
to see the Matza is a Mitzva,
to eat the Matza is a mitzvah, to be in a total Yetzias Mitzrayim mode where we
literally and metaphorically go to war against chometz.
We take no survivors. Then we have Sukkos, the arms, the
Arba Minim, the Sukka. In
the Sukka you can do 4 mitvos
with the entire body at one time; living in
Now we are going into the third month from Yetzias Mitzrayim. We are going
into the 46th day and beyond. We are reaching up on the spiral
stairway to eternity. We count each day – another sefira,
another tikkun. We count up to 49 but, as we asked
last week, how is it that we can’t count 50? What
happened? Why does nobody count 50? Its like climbing
It is forbidden to count Jews. But now H commands us in Parshas Bamidbar to count. The book of Bamidbar deals with the laws and journeys of the Mishcan in the wilderness. The Ramban notes that that the parallel between the Mishcan as seen through the light of these laws and the revelation at Sinai. This suggests that the Mishcan, later the Mikdash and now the Beis Hamikdash Me’at, the Beis Knesses is to serve as replacement for the Heavenly presence that rested at Har Sinai. It was so profound that Bnei Yisrael said Be Lev Ehad UBeguf Ehad, Naase Venishma, amru ehad. We have reached the level beyibd Yaakov, beyond the name Yisrael which he received when he conquered the angel of Esav. He reached a level for one second which in the course of History we will return to, he reached the level of Yeshurun. Then they became fat, gross and kicked out. When he kicked out he blew out. We were allowed to go in our own ways which led us astray. That tragic impediment, impurity, in the heart and mind of the nation, that led us on a 3,300 year voyage that has led us away from eternity, how can it be that H’ leaves the door of Teshuva open. If you return to me, if you show me just the key to the door. If you return to me like the eye of a needle, I will return to you completely. So this Mikdash Me’at, the synagogue, is our last remnant in Galus of our return to the Mishkan, it is our stairway to Heaven. It serves as a substitute for the heavenly presence that rested amongst Am Yisrael. By making the Mishkan central to the nation, not only physically, but conceptually, the people would keep the high Sinai experience, just as they had surrounded the mountain longing for closeness to H’, they would camp around the Mishkan’s symbolism, as their very existence was dictated and determined by their closeness to Torah. According to the book of Bamidbar, which contains the commandments to safeguard the Mishkan, for the tribes to be arranged it, and for the Cohanima nd Leviim to conduct the protection and the service within, it was dismantled, transported and protected by the Cohanim and the Leviim. All of these enhanced the glory and the prestige of the Mishkan as illustrated by the parable of the Sages. A Royal palace that is not safeguarded by loyal servants is unlike one that is not safeguarded at all. Just think of a palace where the gardens are not being nurtured. Where the garden is not being looked after by the servants. What authority does the King have over his servants working in the garden? And all the moreso, somebody working in the garden, how does he reflect upon the King in the palace? The windows are dirty, the palace is dirty, the garbage is piling up outside the Palace, what kind of a King is it inside that palace, whose servants aren’t listening to Him. On the contrary, the gardens are impeccable, the fences are gold and silver – incredible incredible opulence and prestige.
As we come to the seventh week of the Sefira,
where everything is on
the Sefira of Malchius,
we reflect on Chesed Shbelamchius
and Gevuro Shebemalchius,
and the ultimate level, to reach Malchius Shebemalchius, where the King comes to his Royal window and
he looks over the masses and sees everybody that made it to the 50th
level and all of a sudden the palace door opens, and everybody rushes in to the
eternal banquet, Olam Haze to Olam
Haba. So to reflect on what Shakespeare, ironically,
the anti-Semite had to say, where he described Shylock as a disgusting, evil
thieving Jew, which was curiously enough an expression of anti-semitism, another point he got so tragically wrong was when
he said, if there are weeds in the garden, you can be sure that all is not well
in the Palace. That is correct is the gardeners, the servants in the garden of
the King are not performing their responsibility, for sure the King does not
have Shlita on them, the ability to rule the Kingdom,
all the moreso his own garden and all the moreso his own palace. Overthrowal
of the kingdom is imminent. We might expect, Has VeSHalom,
that the King would be executed and overthrown at any moment by somebody who
figures that he can un this Kingdom better. Such things happened to the
generation of Noach. They felt that they knew better
than the 7 mitzvos shel B’nei
Noach. The Do Haniflaga, of
the
Counting the Nation
H’ commands to count Bnei Yisroel, with the anticipation that they would take a tribe
by tribe census to divide the land. Rashi comments very interestingly. It is
forbidden to count the nation, even a minyan. Now H
commands us - please count. Even more curios, H who knows everything in every
generation, how many stars there are, every blade of grass, every grain of
sand in his Universe. H asks us to count for him. Rashi comments, because of
H’s love for the people of Yisrael he asks us to count frequently, before Yetzias Mitzrayim, after the sin
of the Golden Calf to see how many loyal ones of am Yisrael were left. Now at
the revelation at
Secondly, every member of the nation had a right to benefit personally from Moshe and Aharon. The census was a great opportunity for every Jew to come before the father of all prophets, and his brother, and their Father, Hakadosh B”H and tell them his name, the person that had survived, and to be counted as an individual for his personal worth and surely Moshe and Aharon would bless them individually and pray for them, and that half shekel contribution would bring them an infinite atonement.
Thirdly, the people about to go into Eretz Yisroel would, had they not sinned, in the tragic episode of the spies, a census was needed to prepare the military campaign and to know how many people were eligible to receive portions also in the land. Of course H knew what would happen, but Moshe and Aharon did not and the nation did not. This was a rare moment, a rare glimpse into why H’ commanded that we should know, for ourselves, what their numbers were.
Now we preprare ourselves for the military campaign, for the spiritual campaign, for the campaign of the inheritance and the heritage.
The Tribes were counted according to their families. Rav
Yaakov Kaminetzky zt”l
explains that the Census in Exodus counted the Nation as a whole but those
censuses in Numbers count the tribes separately. A tent was established as the Central symbol
in Jewish life, the Mishkan- the sanctuary, brought a
danger that one’s identity would rest with his own tribe and that this would,
as it did at certain times in history, to division and conflict where one tribe
felt that they had to dominate another tribe. When this happened there was an
infinite danger that the whole group could disintegrate. Factionalism is
replaced with unity. From unity comes strength and from factionalism comes
factionalism, being fractioned, fractioned, destroyed. Once it was established
that all tribes looked to the Mishkan, and to H’
their primary unifying force. This way the establishment of tribes would be
healthy. Each tribe has its individual mission, which is unique. Each
individual has his individual position. The nation cannot go forward without
each unique independent thread of infinity, then each tribe would realise that
it is independent and individual ability should be developed for the service of
the klal,
According to their father’s household. The sons’ tribal affiliation is according to their father ie his tribal identity cannot be through his mother. His father had to be Jewish. If Has Ve Shalom she did not marry a Jew, the children would not belong to any tribe. On the other hand, if the father married a gentile, heaven forbid, his Jewish identity is not identified, let alone which tribe he came from. For example a Jew with a father from Yehuda and a mother from Asher, belonged to Yehuda. This is Rashi. The nationality, however, is according to the mother. The child of a gentile mother and Jewish father is not Jewish at all. I know of a family where the first born is a Yisrael, and the second child is a Levi. How can this be? Both children are born from the same father and mother. If the father discovered after the first child that he is a Levi, the first child is a Levi. If he knew that he was a Levi to begin with, how could the first child be a Yisroel? In fact, the mother was a gentile to begin with. She then converted and married her husband according to the laws of Moshe MiSinai. The first child converted with the mother. The first child that converted with the mother was a Yisroel. The second child, born in Jewish wedlock, got his correct patrilineage. An amazing story.
The name, Shemos, was a great one
for each person, he was given his name as an
individual. To Moshe and Aharon, according to Rambam, at that point in world history, a person’s name was
divinely inspired. The parents got that name through nevua
to indicate his personal virtues and mission in this world. In the census
before the people crossed the
Now we want to explore he aberration of the census. Was
there consensus, in the census? Rashi, Exodus 30,16
notes an unusual coincidence. The census given at Yetzias
Mitzrayim had to have been conducted before the Mishcan was built. The half shekel used to make the count
was used to support the structure, the sockets, while the census, the counting
detailed here happened nearly 7 months later. How is it possible that both
populations totaled 603,550. The number was identical
in the counting before Yetzias Mitzrayim
and the counting when the Tora was about to be received. How can you understand
this? Was nobody born in the nation? Did nobody pass away in the nation? Surely
many people died or came of age, to the age of
Having proven their loyalty to H at the time of the Golden Calf, as Moshe called out to the people in the tragedy of that episode, Mi Leshem Elay- He who is for H stand up. Sons stood up, fathers stood up. They slaid those involved in the worship of the Golden Calf. The Leviim were elevated because of what they did to become H‘s own guard, his own legion. The new status was given expression in 3 ways; (1) the Leviim would be counted separately and differently from the rest of the population, (2) there would be a guard to guard the Mishkan and the Courtyard. They had detailed information how to assemble and disassemble the Mishkan and transport it during the travels in the dessert. The Leviim’s camp which surrounded the Mishkan. The rest of nation formed four groups of 3 tribes. This corresponded to Yerushalayim. The Beis Hamikdash – including the Kodesh Hakodashim, Kodesh and Azara – the holiness of the Cohanim, the holiness of Har Habayis – corresponding to the Mishkan - the holiness of the Leviim and the whole city – the Holiness of Yisroel.
You shall not count, You shall not take a census. This verse refers to the two ways that the Leviim are distinct from the nation. They will not be counted from the age of 20 and up. They will be counted specially, in respect to the their highest spiritual faculty. Alternatively, H knew that all those at the ordinary level would die in the wilderness. The Leviim were excluded from this fate because of their courage in the incident of the Golden Calf. That is Rashi. The Ibn Ezra says that they were to serve from the rest of the tribes. They are treated as H’s own legion, to learn and teach. They are hand picked from every Yeshiva and Kolel across the world to learn His Torah to be an inner guardian, to bring his soul to a perfect act of Emuna. When they come back every night to learn Torah, H counts every single one.
Even before this commandment, Moshe says that he could not
count the Leviim with the others. H did not appoint
them a leader because they are a tribe of leaders. So says the Rambam. Now we look at a very interesting thing. The Mishkan was transported whilst deconstructed. If a stranger
touched them, they would die. This is divinely imposed, rather than through any
Beis Din or Zealot, this was surely to be carried out by H’. Anyone who crosses
the threshold, H will personally deal with him according to Rashi.
Leviim and Cohanim could
also not enter beyond a certain point. This is not to say a Yisrael
could not enter the Mishkan in purity for a specific
purpose. The purpose of the Leviim is to be a guard.
The purpose was not so much to protect the Mishkan.
As we see from the journeying in the desert and the carrying of the Aron Hakodesh. More than the Leviim were carrying the Aron Hakodesh,
the Aron Hakodesh was
carrying them. This is immortalized in the famous story of when David Hamelech was bringing the Aron
back on the Ox Wagon. It looked at one point as though it was going to fall.
Somebody reached out to try and support the Aron
which looked as though it would fall. Halila. Because of his lack of faith, he was struck dead. This is
like the guards of Royal Palaces who, by standing guard, give awe to the Royal
family. This is according to the Mishna in Middos,1, 1. Each tribe according to his banner.
According to their insignias. What are their
insignias? They represent the deep spiritual qualities of the tribes. Each flag
was the same colour as the stone on the breast plate
of the Cohen Gadol. Each colour
was a different colour. Bamidbar
Raba 2.6 says that Reuvens
was red and his insignia was dudaim – the special
flowers that he brought to his mother, Leah. Shimons
was green and emroided on it was the city of
Having described the tribes, H legends the royal servants, outlining their formation, H lists hi royal honour guards, His Cohanim and Leviim, bringing the inner sanctity immediately around the Mishkan, who devoted their lives to His service. H commanded Moshe to bring the Leviim before Aaron and formally designate them as servants of the Cohanim, representatives of the Nation, safeguarding the sanctity and assisting in the Avodass H’.
The Talmud in Sanhedrin 19b wonders why this passage describing the offspring of Aaron and Moshe is described, why this passage only mentions the sons of Aharon. The Torah calls them the offspring of Moshe and Aharon. Surely they are the offspring of Aharon HaCohen. From this description, the Torah learns that one who teaches Torah to somebody else’s children, it is as if he had given birth to that child. He receives the spiritual reward along with the father. Because he taught the Torah to Aaron’s four sons, Moshe became their spiritual father. Just as Aaron was their biological father. According to Rashi and Ramban, the mortal and moral implication of this lesson is that man’s horizon can never be limited to his physical circle of family and friends. One example and one way of treating those around him is a guide and can give light to every Jew across the world. For every Jew across the world who brings another Jew to Teshuva, he is like their spiritual father. How great is the reward to Rabbi Horowitz, this Yeshiva, of this Nation, that we are our brother’s keepers. Al taamod al dam reecha. We will not see our brother’s blood being shed when we are there. Ahavta LeRe’cha Kamocha, Love our brother as ourselves. In so doing, H will love us unconditionally, because we love our brother unconditionally. It says about the appointment of the Leviim, they shall serve H’. Moshe wanted to take the Leviim before Aaron so that they would be consecrated for the service of H’. This is spelt out in the following verse; the Cohanim and Cohen Gadol, carried the ultimate responsibility to safeguard the sanctuary and sanctity of the Kodesh HaKedoshim. The Leviim assisted in doing this on an ongoing basis. Malbim comments that the Leviim were involved in the Temple service as well because the Leviim would sing the praises and play the instruments as the offerings were being brought to H’ taking it further, to infinite heights.
May we continue as a nation, to sing H’s praises from here on and forever more, this Rosh Chodesh, we said Halel this morning, this Shabbos, with the Nishamas Kol Hai and all the beautiful tefillos on Shabbos, with the Halle, the Musaf all the prayers that H wants and may our prayers be answered. May we see the Beis Hamikdash bimheiro veyameinu, the Cohen Gadol, Am Yisrael BiTshuvas Gamur, the Kibutz Galiyos, not a Kibbutz like you see in Israel today but like that which H had in mind for us, respecting the land as required by the Torah according to the way that H had designed it at the beginning of time, Tehiyas Hameisim, the revival of the dead, may we all celebrate Olam Haba in Olam Hazeh.
How does H love us? 613 ways.
Good Shabbos.